hegel.net - Homepage   Articles   Life   Phenomenology   System   Reception   Resources   Poster+CD   Game   Info  
Triangle   FAQ   e-Texts   Hyptertext   Links   Discuss   Sitemap   Email    de en fr it es br nl

 

United or sovereign nations?

Grimsmann/Hansen March 2003

 

In view of the current Iraq crisis,
the contradiction between the self-determination of a state
and the subordination under a world government appears clearly again.

So, for example, on the one hand the USA respects the UN
to make the decision about war and peace,
on the other hand they make the decision for themselves.


Kant already dreamed of an eternal world peace,
that is supposed to be produced and guaranteed
by the democratic peoples partnership.

To many people this dream seems to be not far away from realization.

The activity of the USA to them is an inconceivable step backwards.

But as long as the peoples partnership will be constituted of sovereign countries
this contradiction will continue.

A true union under a higher force monopoly
would mean at the same time to give up the own sovereignty.


The world is lead by states not by the international law of the UN,
Hegel shows this fact as a necessity wich is determinated
by the concept of the state and the international law itself.

The relation between the states is the first negation of the concept of the sovereign countries.

As such the first negation is in the opposite to the autonomy
but at the same time it is based on and presupposed it.

In the UN, the countries are unified to respect their independance.

Until today, Hegel's statements go well together with the reality of the world.

And the goal of a scientific philosophy is to find the necessity in reality,
not to fantasize about an utopian world.



Email? [email protected]

^
Copyright © 2004 by hegel.net, Martin Grimsmann (Hamburg)/Lutz Hansen (Hamburg).
Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version
published by the Free Software Foundation, with no Invariant Sections, with no Front-Cover Texts, and with no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license
can be found here: "GNU Free Documentation License".

This work is also licensed under a Creative Commons License.
This work is also licensed under a Creative Commons Developing Nations license.

Questions? Criticism? Want to participate? Send an Email to the webmaster.

Terms of Use   Privacy Policy